Inter-Research |
IR Home
Journals Home MEPS AME CR DAO ESEP ESR Search Subscribe Book Series EE Books Top Books ESEP Books Order EEIU Brochures (pdf format) Discussion Forums Home Research IR Research Institutions International Ecology Institute Eco-Ethics International Union Foundation Otto Kinne Foundation |
THE PASTWithin less than 25 years, MEPS grew from 1 volume per year (1979) to 20 volumes per year (2002) . An increasing number of prominent colleagues joined MEPS and assumed responsibilities as Contributing Editors and Review Editors; in addition, several hundred experts served as Anonymous Staff Referees and as occasional referees. These colleagues, the authors who published their work in the journal, and the technical IR Staff in Oldendorf/Luhe have helped make MEPS the world-wide leader in its field. Additional scientific journals were founded: Diseases of Aquatic Organisms (an offspring of the Treatise Diseases of Marine Animals); Climate Research; Aquatic Microbial Ecology; Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics; Endangered Species Research. New institutions were created and sponsored by IR: the International Ecology Institute and the Eco-Ethics International Union; the Otto Kinne Foundation was established; and 3 book series were started: Excellence in Ecology, Top Books and ESEP Books.
THE PRESENTBeginning in 1989, Inter-Research Science Center has sponsored and conducted Research on endangered species, especially amphibians. For details consult Endangered Species Research, 2004. IR has devoted much time and effort to developing quality control of submitted manuscripts and to introducing formalised procedures for criticising IR-published information (e.g. Kinne 2002, 2003b). It has thus made salient contributions to the evolution of the scientific process (Kinne 1988). While the peer review process provides time-proven ways of judging the scientific merits of submitted manuscripts, it is not perfect (e.g. Riisgård 2000, 2003, 2004; Browman & Kirby 2004). It cannot include all pertinent aspects nor exclude misjudgements. IR has therefore underlined the importance of direct post-publication critique (Kinne 2002). The ultimate judgement of published scientific papers is, of course, made by the international scientific community. Nevertheless, an article published in 'Climate Research' has generated strong criticism and even (unsuccessful) attempts to boycott the journal - apparently not only on scientific grounds, but also fuelled by political and economic interests (for details see Kinne 2003a). Of course, criticism from forces outside the scientific process is welcome. But such forces should not be allowed to interfere with acknowledged mechanisms of "truth-finding". We cannot tolerate lobbyists in science, nor inquisitors. The integrity of the scientific process is the heart of science; it must not be compromised.
THE FUTUREIn January 2005 I appointed my historically first helpers (in the sequence they joined me) to important positions: Helga Witt to Administrative Director, Helga Kinne to Financial Director, John Austin to Production Director. Of course, for the future of IR the most important position is that of Scientific Director. I am pleased to have appointed Professor Howard I. Browman to this key position. Howard is an internationally highly respected scientist whose professional career, abilities and interests are, in my view, tailor-made for this responsibility. I have co-operated with Howard for an extensive period of time and I know he will give IR sustained scientific leadership. I hope that authors, editors and reviewers will share my enthusiasm. Howard has begun taking on responsibilities with IR, while also remaining actively involved in research through his position with the Institute of Marine Research in Norway. I am confident that the local IR staff will be as loyal to Howard as they have been to me. After retiring from my position as Leading Director and Professor of the Biologische Anstalt Helgoland many years ago, I have spent much time developing IR into what I see as the second part of my professional life achievement. I consider Howard Browman the right person to oversee and develop this accomplishment. Inter-Research Symposia: IR has spent a considerable percentage of its taxable income on supporting science, education, ethics and endangered species research. Consistent with this tradition, and in celebration of our 25th anniversary, we are pleased to announce the initiation of 'Inter-Research Symposia'. IR will support these Symposia meant to address cutting-edge topics. At the beginning, Symposium themes will be chosen by the IR President and the Scientific Director, who will also organise and moderate them. Selected papers presented at these Symposia will be published quickly in one of the IR journals. The IR Symposia are planned to be convened in conjunction with major international conferences.
CLOSING WORDS
LITERATURE CITEDKinne O (1988) The scientific process - its links, functions and problems. Naturwissenschaften 75: 275-279 Kinne O (2002) A word from the publisher: Importance and organisation of direct post-publication critique. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 228: 1 Kinne O (2003a) Climate Research: an article unleashed world-wide storms. Clim Res 24: 197-198 Kinne O (2003b) Quality control in science: recruiting, protecting and controlling the controllers. Clim Res 25: 1 Kinne O (2004) Quality assessment and improvement of manuscripts. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 279: 1 Riisgård HU (2000) MEPS Theme Section: The peer-review system: time for re-assessment? Mar Ecol Prog Ser 192: 305-313 Riisgård HU (2003) MEPS Theme Section: Misuse of the peer review system: time for countermeasures? Mar Ecol Prog Ser 258: 297-300 Riisgård HU (2004) MEPS Theme Section: Peer review: journal articles versus research proposals. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 277: 301-309
|
Copyright © 2005; Inter-Research
Webmaster: webmaster@int-res.com |